Here’s the harsh truth: despite the Cincinnati Reds’ recent reunion with Eugenio Suárez, their roster still feels like it’s missing that one wildcard piece—a seasoned veteran who could tip the scales in their favor. But here’s where it gets controversial: it’s not another bat or even a guaranteed starter they need. It’s the kind of player who’s been there, done that, but might just need a tweak to rediscover their magic. And this is the part most people miss—it’s not about perfection; it’s about potential upside without the pressure of immediate results.
The Reds’ lineup is undeniably stronger with Suárez’s bat, but his addition complicates playing time for prospects like Spencer Steer, Sal Stewart, Ke’Bryan Hayes, and JJ Bleday. Yet, this flexibility is a double-edged sword. With a roster full of moving parts and only Elly De La Cruz as a true everyday player, injuries or slumps are inevitable. The same goes for their starting rotation. Chase Burns, Rhett Lowder, Brandon Williamson, and Julian Aguiar could theoretically provide a massive boost, but depth is never a bad thing. Just look at last season: despite having a stacked rotation, the Reds still relied on Nick Martinez, Zack Littell, and even a returning Wade Miley to eat innings.
Speaking of Miley, his story is a perfect example of what’s missing this year. A year ago, he was the quintessential bargain-bin veteran—a reclamation project with upside. The Reds didn’t need him to succeed, but if he did, it was a bonus. That low-risk, high-reward gamble is absent from this year’s camp. There’s no one on the roster who fits that mold—a player with a proven track record but recent struggles, someone who could be molded back into form without the pressure of being a savior.
And this is where it gets even more controversial: What if the Reds took a chance on someone like Walker Buehler? A two-time All-Star, World Series champion, and former Cy Young contender who’s fallen on hard times after elbow surgery? At 31, he’s not past his prime, but his recent stats (5.10 ERA, 5.62 FIP) and declining fastball velocity raise eyebrows. Yet, his connection to the Reds—growing up in Kentucky, being part of Derek Johnson’s recruiting class at Vanderbilt—adds a layer of intrigue. Could Johnson, now with the Reds, help Buehler rediscover his form?
Here’s the kicker: Buehler wouldn’t need to be Opening Day ready or pitch six innings every fifth day. He could be a Martinez-like figure—a versatile arm who slots into the bullpen or rotation as needed. Sure, he’s flawed, and his camp might be holding out for a guaranteed role or higher salary. But if the Reds could sign him without breaking the bank, it’s a risk worth taking. Even if it doesn’t work out, the impact on the roster would be minimal.
So, here’s the question: Is Walker Buehler the missing piece the Reds need, or is he a gamble too far? What do you think? Let’s debate it in the comments—because while the Reds look strong on paper, that one wildcard addition could be the difference between a good season and a great one.
